Skip to content

Ismail Lagardien

in words and images

Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Bookshelf/Reading List
  • The Image
Menu

The Cruelty of Deliberate Forgetting

Posted on 1 October 202019 October 2020 by ilagardien
With the great Alf Khumalo

I am posting this edited version of a talk I gave, three years after it was published in the Mail & Guardian. It was not a paid assignment. I am placing it here as a type of community service/outreach/

The 1980s — represented in the exhibition Between States of Emergency: Photographers in Action 1985-1990 — were a time when the country was terribly divided. The majority of the population looked at the state with fear and anxiety — our faces pinned to the ground by a military jackboot.

These photographs remind us of those desperate times. The economy had all but collapsed. The government was in disarray. The ruling elite was fractured.

There were protests around the country, and the military and police had invaded the townships and our homes. There is cold comfort in the observation that “those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it”.

So, yes, more than 30 years ago I photographed death and dying during that dark and brutal period of successive states of emergency between 1985 and 1990. I should not be disingenuous and add hastily that I was an average reporter and a rubbish photographer.

I took the photographs at a time when I, personally, and we, the public, wrestled with conditions in the country. We were a deeply divided society teetering on the edge of an abyss of racial and ethnic violence and brute repression. The period when the pictures were taken was a time of intense state violence, censorship and persecution — part of decades-long policies of banning particular literature and photographs from being published or disseminated.

The clever people may insist that anything that is photographed represents something from the past and, simultaneously, undergoes a shift in time. The gesture of photography becomes both an act of preservation and of de-creation. It is documented evidence that something happened, or that someone died, but the photograph is also proof positive, somehow, of a life event and a lived past.

Other clever people may argue that the photograph presents an objective reality, and that the photographer’s work is a true record of what happened in an earlier period. But we overlook the subjectivity of the act of photography.

I read that the gesture of photography was different from those of other visual arts. Photography goes beyond the purely technical and becomes an intellectual exercise, which includes careful consideration, observation and learning to look at the same things that others do but to see it differently. With photography you learn to see relationships between shadows and lights.

With my brief experience and limited knowledge of social documentary photography, I get the sense that there is a powerful relationship between what you capture and your own sensibilities. It was never easy to photograph acts of cruelty and brutality.

More than 20 years after these photographs were taken, looking at them now helps me to understand in a very limited way the banality of power in the post-colony. I want to make the point that so much of what we are going through today is a mirror image of the obscenity and grotesquery of the previous regime.

As philosopher and political theorist Achille Mbembe points out, these excesses and grotesqueries include the elaborate inaugural ceremonies, acts of violence and terror, large-scale pillaging and elaborate protocols of showing deference.

In the wake of the catastrophic Cabinet reshuffle at the end of March, ANC Youth League leader Collen Maine told an audience of party loyalists that the fired finance minister, Pravin Gordhan, had to be dealt with in the way that activists “dealt with” the izimpimpi — informers, collaborators — during the anti-apartheid struggle.

His exhortation was jarring (on a very personal level — the level that the researcher or the journalist is required to leave at the door) and evoked memories of the times when, as a reporter and photojournalist, I witnessed cruelty and brutality, from the East Rand to Boipatong, Kigali, Mogadishu and Srebrenica.

In South Africa, I witnessed acts of violence against the izimpimpi — that horrifying method of “necklacing” — that shook the sensibilities of the best and the worst of us in the dark days of the 1980s. Hiding behind my viewfinder, I saw violence and brutality that was, at first, shocking, though after a while it became banal … until Maine called on party loyalists to deal with Gordhan in the way the izimpimpi were dealt with.

One of the cruellest and most brutal things I saw was a woman lying flat on the red earth, with large slabs of rock and concrete dropped on her head and body — and then she was set alight. What was her crime? She was suspected of being an impimpi. All I could do was photograph it.

In the weeks that passed since Maine’s exhortation to treat Gordhan as an impimpi, several questions come to the fore. How could the leader of the youth league forget the horrors, the cruelty and brutality and structural violence of our past? Has he forgotten the violent deeds committed in the name of the most honourable of causes? Or has the violence of the “good forces” received sacerdotal sanction because it was against a system of oppression?

At the base of these questions are some of the eternal struggles between remembering and forgetting. How or why do we remember or forget? Perhaps the most difficult of all is whether we should forget.

Of course, we should assume goodness in every human and imagine that Maine did not remember the violence against the izimpimpi, and that it was not intentional forgetting or because of the inaccessibility of memory. We can assume, in other words, that his statement was a case of the unavailability of (personal) memory being more powerful than collective memory.

This raises important issues about remembering and forgetting as we battle to forge a new society. Let me be clear: there were several flames during those fiery times — the attacks on so-called collaborators were but one of them. What we are dealing with now, though, is a leader of the state-party nexus of democratic South Africa who mirrors that grotesquery of the old regime.

One of the strands that can be picked from all of this is the way in which people actively and sometimes purposefully choose to forget. My sense is that there is a very thin line between types of forgetting.

By now, most South Africans are familiar with the expression that we should forget the past and just “move on”. Invariably, it is the erstwhile oppressor who would insist that subsequent generations should take from the past what was good and leave behind what was bad. It is an elision of prescriptive forgetting and a type of repressive erasure; a cross between destroying one set of mnemonic devices (or events) and simply putting new things in place to represent the present and construct new social identities.

It is not inconceivable that Maine’s comments were based on a structural or selective amnesia; the type of forgetting in which individuals choose to remember some things, and not to remember what they don’t want to.

What does remain clear is that his exhortations placed differential values on human life. Gordhan and Maki Skosana, the woman who was killed in the most cruel and brutal way, are considered izimpimpi and therefore less human. They have to be dealt with, possibly, in the cruellest and most brutal way.

To paraphrase Roland Barthes on authorship, the photographers whose works are displayed in this exhibition present the viewers with responsibility. The viewer is the surface on which everything that has been photographed is inscribed. What is captured in each photograph lies not in its origin but in its destination. So, as viewers, we may make of these photographs what we wish.

Nonetheless, the photographs are reminders of our past. The past, it is safe to say, is a time that carries guilt and the future represents only innocence — for no injustice has yet been committed.

With respect to the youth league leader, I will say this: it is difficult to imagine that those who reproduce unspeakable violence in the name of justice are anything more than thoughtless functionaries.

Ismail Lagardien is the executive dean of business and economics sciences at Nelson Mandela University. This is an edited version of a talk given at the opening of the exhibition Between States of Emergency: Photographers in Action 1985-1990, at the NMMU Bird Street Art Gallery in Port Elizabeth, which is on until May 19

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

RSS Financial Times

  • No signs of US slowdown in surprisingly robust jobs market
  • Corporate America is divided on odds of US recession
  • Indian authorities seek to calm investors after Adani sell-off
  • Corruption in Europe: a continent divided
  • Sunak under pressure from growing Raab row and critical ex-PMs

RSS Branko Milanovic Personal Blog

  • Why I think that Argentina 1985 is not a very good movie
    Now when the passions have receded a bit after I got an incredible number of critiques and insulting emails because I did but think that Argentina 1985 is a very good movie I would like to explain my reasons. First, let me say that the critique of a film or a book is totally separate […]
  • The Madoff enigma
                I watched a four-part excellent documentary on Bernie Madoff’s“scam of the century”. (The series is not exactly a documentary because most scenes are re-enacted, but this is done in a very good, and rather discrete, way, combining the actual footage with the enacting, so that we can still call it a documentary). The film […]
  • Distinguishing incomes from capital and labor
               When I recently received my copy-edited chapter dealing with Adam Smith (from my forthcoming book "Visions of Inequality"), I noticed that in several instances the editor changed my “the rate of profit on capital” to the “rate of profit on investment” or “profits on invested capital”. I changed it back to the original, but […]
  • Not a new Xi
                In today’s Financial Times Ruchir Sharma has a very nice article about the recent readjustments in China’s policies: discontinuation of zero-covid restrictions, stronger support for globalization, and a nod toward the private sector.  As the title (“The Xi nobody saw coming”) says, Sharma sees them as a sudden and […]
  • The book of the dead: Victor Serge's Notebooks 1936-47
            Born to Russian anti-Czarist emigrés in Belgium in 1890 => engaged in revolutionary anarchist activity as a teenager in France => condemned to five years in jail at 17 => expelled to Spain => exchanged for French soldiers held by the Bolsheviks in 1919 => joined the Bolsheviks => participated in the Civil […]

RSS BBC World News

  • Perth shark attack: Teenage girl dies in Swan River
  • Chris Parry and Andrew Bagshaw's bodies recovered in prisoner swap - Ukraine
  • Japan PM fires aide over derogatory LGBT remarks
  • China urges calm over 'spy' balloon in US airspace
  • Tyre Nichols: Sixth police officer fired

RSS Channelnews Asia

  • Sri Lanka completing pre-requisites for IMF aid - President
  • Ukraine, Russia swap prisoners; bodies of British volunteers returned
  • Pakistan blocks Wikipedia over 'blasphemous content'
  • Perth Scorchers edge Brisbane Heat in BBL final to retain title
  • Skriniar no longer Inter captain says Inzaghi ahead of Milan derby

RSS Singapore Straits Times

  • Goodbye Iowa! Democrats approve Biden's revamped primary calendar
  • Biden says US is 'going to take care of' Chinese balloon
  • 500,000 households in Ukraine's Odesa without power
  • Frostbite in 5 minutes: Northeast US, Canada gripped by Arctic blast
  • Avalanches in Austria, Switzerland kill five

RSS Business Times

  • Bankruptcy applications hit 17-year high in 2022, after tapering of Covid-era support
    BANKRUPTCY applications by individuals in Singapore rose to a 17-year high last year, but applications for companies to be compulsorily liquidated dipped – trends which lawyers and economists say could be due to business owners being included in the personal bankruptcy figures.
  • Malaysia proposes new way to ease Singapore Causeway traffic
    THERE may be relief for 150,000 commuters who endure hours-long waits to cross the road border from Malaysia to Singapore, The Star reported.
  • Daily Debrief: What Happened Today
    Stories you might have missed
  • Consumers lost over S$645,000 in prepayments in 2022, beauty industry saw highest losses: Case
    CONSUMERS lost more than S$645,000 in prepayments in 2022 because of the sudden closure of businesses, with the beauty industry accounting for the highest amount of losses, followed by the travel industry.
  • Temasek-backed fish farmer Apollo Aquaculture in judicial management
    FISH farm Apollo Aquaculture Group is currently in judicial management, according to a filing with the Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (Acra).

RSS The Economist

  • Politics
  • Business
  • KAL’s cartoon
  • This week’s cover
    How we saw the world
  • Business

RSS Malay Mail

  • Menu Rahmah will be available at IPTA after Aildilfitri, says Salahuddin
  • Malaysia, Singapore to work together to tackle online scams
  • Malaysia, Singapore reaffirm bilateral cooperation in three areas

Tags

2022 Amir Mohammad architecture black and white book Books Chrome Cities city colour culture DSLR Empire Podcast FatBidin Film Film maker food heritage history iPhone iphonephotography Istanbul Johannesburg Kuala Lumpur Malaysia Melaka memoir Mexican modernisation Nikon paris personal photography podcast race review Sheril A Bustaman skyscraper South Africa sport too white to be coloured to coloured to be black travel Turkey writing Zan Azlee

Categories

  • Architecture (2)
  • Art (8)
  • Asia (8)
  • Astronomy (1)
  • Books (2)
  • Cape Malay (6)
  • Cities (18)
  • City Scapes (1)
  • Cosmology (1)
  • Culture (7)
  • Culture (12)
  • Economics (1)
  • Family (3)
  • Family Roots (7)
  • Film (2)
  • Food (5)
  • Global Finance (1)
  • Heritage (10)
  • Identity (5)
  • Istanbul (2)
  • Istanbul (4)
  • Journalism (1)
  • Makanan (4)
  • Malaysia (10)
  • Melaka (3)
  • Memory (6)
  • On Writing (4)
  • Personal (2)
  • Photography (22)
  • Physics (1)
  • Politics (7)
  • Race (6)
  • Racism (2)
  • Random Shots (8)
  • Science (1)
  • Social Justice (3)
  • Social Media (1)
  • South Africa (2)
  • South East Asia (7)
  • Sport (2)
  • Turkey (4)
  • Uncategorised (1)
  • Vlog (1)
  • War (1)
  • Web Development (1)
  • Western Asia (1)
  • Writing (6)

Archives

  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • June 2021
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • June 2020
  • December 2012

Categories

  • Architecture
  • Art
  • Asia
  • Astronomy
  • Books
  • Cape Malay
  • Cities
  • City Scapes
  • Cosmology
  • Culture
  • Culture
  • Economics
  • Family
  • Family Roots
  • Film
  • Food
  • Global Finance
  • Heritage
  • Identity
  • Istanbul
  • Istanbul
  • Journalism
  • Makanan
  • Malaysia
  • Melaka
  • Memory
  • On Writing
  • Personal
  • Photography
  • Physics
  • Politics
  • Race
  • Racism
  • Random Shots
  • Science
  • Social Justice
  • Social Media
  • South Africa
  • South East Asia
  • Sport
  • Turkey
  • Uncategorised
  • Vlog
  • War
  • Web Development
  • Western Asia
  • Writing

Anti-G8 and Anti-War Graffiti in Geneva 2003

Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003
Anti-war paint. Geneva 2003

Bastakiya, Dubai 2012

Workers. Heads bowed down in the heat

Verona

© 2023 Ismail Lagardien | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme